Month: January 2023

Brown dwarf story intro scene draft

The water rushed out of the mouth of the pitcher at a steep angle, missing the glass only a handspan below, and spread across the Commander’s desk.

“Oh shit!  I’m sorry Commander.”

The Cadet put down the pitcher and glass and started looking around for something to sop up the water.  Finding nothing, he attempted to corral the spreading puddle with his hands.

The Commander opened a drawer and pulled out a standard PVA zero-gravity hygiene towel.  He handed it to the younger officer.

“Thank you, sir,” the Cadet said.

He ripped oven the plastic bag, unfolded the towel, and began mopping up the mess.

“Coriolis forces will get you every time” the Commander said, with no hint of annoyance in his voice.

“What sir?”  The Cadet said, while continuing to deal with the spill.

The Commander continued affably.

“Coriolis forces.  It an inertial force that affects objects in reference to rotating bodies.  They are why, on Earth, hurricanes spin counterclockwise and southern hemisphere cyclones spin clockwise.”

“Yes sir.”  The Cadet sounded as nervous as he looked, clearly shaken by the faux pas of not being able to handle the normally pedestrian task of pouring a glass of water in front of his new commanding officer.

“Cadet,” the Commander continued in an avuncular manner.  “What do you know about this station?”

“I read what as provided in the assignment brief, sir.”

The Commander made a noise, somewhere between a sigh and a chuckle and continued.

“This station is located on one of the most extreme places in the galaxy that we can put living beings.  This station floats on the surface of a brown dwarf. Brown dwarfs are often called ‘failed stars’ and are technically classified as ‘sub stellar objects.’  They are between a gas giant planet, like Jupiter, and a star, like our sun.  They have more mass than gas giant, and consequently more gravity, but not enough to sustain nuclear fusion like a star. The brown dwarf we are on now has a mass roughly forty times that of Jupiter but only twelve-percent larger in diameter.”

The Cadet ’s eyes widened at this, the implications of what he just learned dawning on him.

“Then sir, how can we be here?  The gravity should crush us.”

“Yes, it should, but this is a fast-spinning brown dwarf.  This station is neutrally buoyant in the upper atmosphere of the dwarf were the rotational period is seventy-five minutes.  We are experiencing enormous centripetal forces; so much so, that if the star rotated any faster, it might actually come apart.  Those forces balance against the gravitational forces so that at the equator, you will experience one-point-one to one-point-two G’s.  That’s well within a healthy human’s ability to handle.”

“But how does that explain” the Cadet paused and looked sheepish for a moment, “this.”  He finished by waiving his hand over the damp spot on the desk in front of him.

“Like I said, Cadet, Coriolis forces.  If we were exactly at the equator, they would not exist.  Depending on the sub-stellar currents, there are perturbations in our equatorial path.  We vary our position a little bit north or south of the equator.  As we do, the Coriolis forces become more intense. The apparent gravity doesn’t always pull straight down.”

“Is that why I had trouble walking earlier?” Asked the Cadet.

“Precisely, but don’t worry you will acclimate to that as well in time.  In the ancient days of an exclusively seafaring navy, sailors would have to get used to the constant rocking motions of the ships they served on.  It was called ‘getting their sea legs’.  Soon enough you will get your dwarf legs.”

The Cadet let out a brief coughing laugh.

“I think you need a better name for that, sir.”

The Commander grinned.

“You’re probably right.  Let me give you some friendly advice Cadet.”

“Yes, sir.”

“Until you start to get a feel for the gravity variations, sit down to pee.  My first day aboard station I was standing at the head and pissed entirely down my left leg.”

“This,” the Commander continued, addressing the wet towel and desktop.  “Pales in comparison to having to report to attention soaked in piss from thigh to ankle.”

The Cadet’s face went pink as he tried to suppress a laugh.  Such commanding officers who would try to ease in a Cadet on training assignments were rare.  Cadets often told horror stories, passed down from generations of graduating classes and rumors traded at reunions, of senior officers who treated the young men and women with a single pip like little more than dirt.  For a commanding officer to share both such valuable advice and a self-debasing anecdote was a refreshing change from what he was prepared to experience.

“Commander, if I may, why station people here at all?”

“Because, Cadet, this is a location of strategic importance.”

“But that’s what I don’t understand sir.  This station is lightyears from any habitable system in the middle of a galactic dead spot.”

The Commander leaned back in his seat, put his elbows on the armrests, interlaced his fingers, and rested his hands on his belly.  He took a moment to size up the young officer sitting across the desk from him.

“You are familiar with the Alcubierre drive, are you not, Cadet?”

“Yes sir, it’s what drives faster-than-light ships.”

“Not exactly,” the Commander said.

“Faster-than-light travel is not possible in the strictest sense.  All ships are still bound by relativistic physics.  The Alcubierre drive distorts space-time around the ship so that the ship itself is traveling sub-light speed relative to the space that it is in.  The ship, however, is traveling at super-luminal velocity relative to a stationary point of reference.”

“The net effect is faster-than-light travel between two points,” the Cadet replied.

“It’s often referred to as faster-than-light, and yes, for practical purposes it is, but understanding the functionality is important to understanding why this station, and the stations like it are of strategic importance.”

“How so, sir?”

“Tell me, Cadet, what do you know about how A-drives work?”  The Commander believed deeply in the Socratic method.  To do well, a man must be able to apply logic and think is way through any problem before him.  This conversation presented a prime opportunity to see if the young officer before him could measure up to the challenge. The Commander began to take on a professorial demeanor.

The Cadet sat up straight in his chair, the perfect picture of the attentive student.

“Well sir, a ship contains a deuterium fueled high pressure laser fusion reactor.  That reactor powers the sub-light drive and a supercollider.  The supercollider creates strange matter, and that strange matter makes the ship go faster than light.”  The Cadet quickly corrected himself.  “The strange matter distorts space-time for an FTL jump.”

“Correct,” acknowledged the Commander.  “What is the most important regulation when plotting a course using an A-drive?”  The commander asked.

“An Alcubierre drive jump is not to be performed inside the heliopause of a star system.”

“Verbatim from the field manual,” the Commander said.  “But can you tell me why.”

“Ummmm….”  the Cadet droned.  He was puzzled.  He had been diligently trained to follow protocols, not question them.

“Think about what you are doing during a jump,” prompted the Commander.

“You are folding space time.”

“Using what?”

“Strange matter.”

“And that is doing what.”

“Creating gravitational bubble around the ship.”  That last point sounded more like a question than a statement to the Commander.

“And…” the Commander’s voice dragged on the enunciation of the word.

“And if you create a space-time gravitational distortion in the orbital path of a planet you could disrupt the orbit of that planet.”

“Correct.”  The Commander gave the word an approving tone.  “That is why A-drive jumps are only allowed between systems, not within them.  But between star system, how car can a ship jump?”

The Cadet thought for a second.

“To the next system, usually, never more than a few lightyears at a time.”

“Yes,” the Commander said.  “But again, why?”

“Fuel capacity.  It takes an enormous amount of fuel to power the A-drive supercollider.”  The Cadet practically spat out the answer.

“Yes, it does take a lot of fuel, and yes, that is a limitation, but theoretically a ship could carry more fuel and travel further.”

The Cadet was dismayed, he thought his second answer would be correct.

“When your ship is in a jump, what do your forward sensors display?”

“Nothing,” the Cadet said quickly.

“Why?”

The Cadet sat there with a glazed look on his face, staring at the Commander.

“Tell me about long range sensor systems.”  The Commander wanted to give the young man a chance to figure this one out.

“Well sir, there is radar and lidar.”

The Commander looked like he was about to say something.  The Cadet wanted to prove to the Commander that he wasn’t stupid and rushed to finish his thought before the Commander had to give him another hint.

“Radar and lidar both use electromagnetic or light waves.  If you are traveling faster than light, you are traveling faster than your sensors.  You are flying blind.”

“You are flying blind,” repeated the Commander.  “Exactly.  So how do you know where you are going.”

“The ship’s course is determined before the jump from telemetry data provided by jump stations.”

“And welcome to a jump station, Cadet.”  The Commander said beaming.

“Cadet, did you ever do one of those trust building exercises where one person wears a blindfold and has to negotiate an obstacle course using directions provided by a partner who can see?”

“Yes sir, that’s a frequent exercise when assigned to a new practice squad.”

“That, Cadet, is essentially the way interstellar navigation is conducted.  Inside of its space-time bubble, a ship is blind.  It navigates in short jumps through mostly empty interstellar space using telemetry data provided by jump stations that have highly accurate maps of local regions of space, only a few cubic lightyears in size.”

The Cadet felt like he should be taking notes.  He was supposed to be reporting for his first training assignment but his it was more like the classroom time he had as a cadet.  The Cadet noted the irony that the Commander’s causal lesson was far more informative the many of the formal lessons he had from his instructors

“Tell me, what do you know of the history of the Mississippi River?”  The commander’s question was such as shift in topic from the field of interstellar navigation that it caught the Cadet off guard.

“Nothing, sir,” the Cadet replied quizzically.

The Commander shifted his weight and continued in a tone as though he were reminiscing.

“During the heyday of steamboat traffic on the Mississippi River, the river changed so much due to local weather conditions that one navigator could not know the entire river.  Steamboat captains would bring aboard a navigator who knew the river between two ports to chart the course of the steamboat.  At the next port, that navigator would disembark, and a new navigator would come aboard for the next length of river.”

The Cadet began to understand where this anecdote was going.

The Commander continued.

“Times have changed, the ships have changed, and this is not the Mighty Mississip, but the principle is similar.  Each jump station maintains a careful watch of the objects in its region of space and can predict their trajectory with great accuracy.  We plot courses through our region of space, provide that information to the ships that pass through our region of space, navigating them during their jump, and handing them off safely to the next jump station.”

“That makes sense, Sir, but why is this station of such strategic importance?”

“What is the regulation about A-drives in star systems?  You said it earlier.”

“An A-drive jump is not to be performed inside the heliopause of a star system.”

“So, what is the best location to place a jump station to plot interstellar courses?”

“In interstellar space.”

The Commander and Cadet settled into an informal, conversational tone.  This was not a commanding officer grilling a subordinate but experienced man, a mentor, passing on his knowledge and wisdom to the next generation.

“Rogue brown dwarfs are one class of interstellar object.  They have no natural satellites and do not constitute part of a star system.  They, along with rouge planets provide a location with natural gravity to establish a jump station in the interstellar medium.  It is precisely because we are, how did you put it? ‘lightyears from any habitable system in the middle of a galactic dead spot’ that this station is strategically important.  What is the average distance between stars?”

Once again, the Commander had a unique way of ending a thought with a question that seemed to be a non sequitur.  The Cadet made a mental note to be prepared for these sudden shifts in conversation.

“I believe, sir, about five light years.”

“That’s the general answer given, but the more accurate answer, considering space in three dimensions, is roughly one star per cubic parsec.  Jump stations placed in the interstellar medium between stars optimize our ability to navigate between systems.  The number of interstellar rogue objects that have the right conditions to put a jump station on are rare enough that when we find one it is worth the risk of placing one there.”

I’m trying to write more

I’m trying to write more fiction.  In THE OFFICIAL ALPHABETICAL LIST OF AUTHOR SUCCESS, I’m somewhere between U and S, with aspirations of N or M level success.

Honestly, if I ever write something and sell enough of it to take my wife on a dinner date to the Olive Garden, I’ll consider that a success.  If my sales cover not just the food but two glasses of wine as well, I will have exceeded my wildest dreams.

Larry is right about a lot of things, writing is work.  I have a day job, one that I really like, and have no desire to quit.  (To be honest, I think if most of you knew exactly what I do for my day job, you’d be sorely tempted to quit your job and do what I do.)

But between this blog and my day job, Grammarly has me at about 20,000 words per month.  The idea of coming home and diligently slamming out another 20,000 words in my after-hours isn’t all that appealing.

Also, I fucking suck.  I live my life in the Dunning-Kruger trough and I read a lot.

I write, I read what I write, I hate what I wrote because it doesn’t measure up to what I feel like I should be able to write, I delete it, get discouraged, and don’t try again for another week or two.

I am absolutely convinced that there is no way I can put out 50,000 words of this shit, and even if I did, nobody would want to read it anyway.

I just have a few ideas in my head for stories that appeal to me that I’d like to share.

My top three are as follows:

I have an idea for a supernatural zombie story that is heavily inspired by the book Dracula.  It takes place during the Civil War in Louisiana.  The villain is a bokor (evil voodoo shaman) who is an escaped slave.  He is reanimating the dead soldiers to terrorize the local townfolk and plantation owners in revenge for his enslavement.  The group that has to stop him is a mixed bag, a Confederate Officer, a wounded Union Officer, a house slave who is also a voodoo shaman, but a good one, and a few others I haven’t quite figured out.  The house slave shaman would be the Van Helsing of the group.  There is plenty of room for friction and character development within the group, all while fighting zombies with Civil War era weaponry.

A story about a metallurgical consultant who discovers in a failure analysis that the failure wasn’t incidental but deliberate.  The villain is using science to sabotage aircraft in ways law enforcement cannot detect before it happens.  I got really focused on the technical with this one and the villain sort of sucked.  I had an idea recently for a new motivation that I think is better and I might go back to this one again.  I was inspired heavily by a terrible movie (based on a book I’ve never read but should) called No Highway in the Sky.  It’s notable only because it’s the only story I know of that has a metallurgist as the hero.

The third, and most recent is based on a Tweet thread by author Travis Corcoran about fast-rotating Brown Dwarfs.  I have no plot but have been enjoying some world-building while practicing writing horribly shitty dialog.

So… fuck it.

I’m going to start posting drafts because otherwise, this shit will never see the light of day.

 

Tuesday Tunes

Back in the 80’s when I was at University payday always meant a trip down the main drag of collage town.

The trek started at the music store, went to the second music store, followed by the book store, and ended at the ice cream parlor.

There I would have my shake and start reading the latest book I had pulled off the “new arrivals” shelf.

But when I got home, that was when the music went on. I would sit and listen to music from good speakers and good CD player and escape.

One of the artist I stumbled onto was Kate Bush.

She was recently rediscovered when the show Stranger Things featured her music.

Hope you enjoy a trip back in time or if this is your first time, some exposure to that old timey music.

The law of unintended consequences is about to bite NY in the ass

NY Will No Longer Prosecute Children Under The Age Of 12

Children under the age of 12 will no longer face arrest and prosecution for virtually all crimes in New York under a bill signed into law late this week by Gov. Kathy Hochul.

The bill signed by Hochul raises the lower age of the state’s jurisdiction for juvenile delinquency, a move that will prevent those under the age of 12 from arrest except in the case of a homicide.

When the new law takes effect in a year, the lower age will be increased to 12. It’s a move that many criminal justice reform advocates had been pushing for years, noting that children of color are affected at a disproportionate rate.

Across the state, at least 800 children under the age of 12 were arrested by police in 2019, according to the Legal Aid Society. In New York City, about 90% were Black or Hispanic.

Every gang in New York is gonna rush to recruit 10 and 11-year-old kids to be drug mules, traffic illegal guns, and shoplift.

It’s going to be off the wall violence and criminality by children.

But fewer kids will be in juvie so New York will consider it a win.

Readily converted. Updated

Full AR-15 build kit. 5 lowers, jigs, router, and tooling

B.L.U.F.: The Gun Control Act of 1968 doesn’t define “readily”. It doesn’t prohibit converting to a frame or receiver, does not prohibit possession of machine gun parts. Readily converted is very dependent on equipment, skill and knowledge.

START-UPDATE

After posting this article I continued my research and stumbled onto the source of the current definition of readily as ATF published it. A few years ago there was a court case. In the court case the judge was asked to if something was “readily converted”. The judge, in their opinion, listed the criteria they used to make that determination. The judge then made the determination.

The ATF copied the language of the opinion on what the criteria the judge used. This is not a definition. This is just how to make a decision. As currently written, the ATF can say “we used the criteria and have determined that this is readily converted.”

Stil, the language of the GCA of 1968 as amendment says that the only thing the ATF can say is if something is or is not a frame or receiver. Readily doesn’t enter into that equation at all.

END-UPDATE

In 1968 then President L.B. Johnson signed into law the Gun Control Act of 1968. This was the first law that significantly intruded into the rights guaranteed under the second amendment.

Prior to this time the worse that had happened was that people had to pay an extra $200 for NFA items. For a long time after the 1934 NFA being caught with a NFA item meant you had to register and pay the stamp tax, nothing more.

The GCA of 1968 gave us

  • FFLs
  • Only FFLs could import, manufacture or deal in firearms or ammunition.
  • Only FFLs could purchase or obtain firearms out of their state of residence
  • Only FFLs could transport destructive devices, machine-guns, SBS or SBR across state lines without permission
  • To give false identification in purchasing or acquiring a firearm
  • For FFLs to sell firearms or ammunition to people less than eighteen years of age
  • For FFLs to sell anything but shotguns or rifles and shotgun and rifle ammunition to people less than 21 years of age
  • Gave state laws the ability to limit who an FFL sold to
  • Require government permission to transfer NFA items
  • Require the FFL to keep a record of who they sell firearms and ammunition to
  • Defined what a prohibited person was:
    • A person under indictment for, or has been convicted in any court of, a crime punishable by imprisonment for a term exceeding one year
    • is a fugitive from justice
    • is an unlawful user of or addicted to marihuana or any depressant or stimulant drug (as defined in section 201(v) of the Federal Food, Durg, and Cosmetic Act) or narcotic drug (as defined in section 4731(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954)
    • Has been adjudicated as a mental defective or has been committed to any mental institution.

    Note that the spelling of “marijuana” is from the actual GCA, not an AWA typo.

  • It is ship firearms or ammunitions without telling the shipper it is a firearm or ammunition, in writing
  • It is unlawful for a shipper to deliver firearms or ammunition to a prohibited person
  • It is unlawful to move a firearm across state lines where the serial number has been removed, obliterated, or altered
  • It is unlawful for an FFL to make a false statement in there their records

In addition, the GCA of 1968 defined what all the “important” terms mean.

(b) Machinegun. — The term ‘machinegun’ means any weapon which shoots, is designed to shoot, or can be readily restored to shoot, automatically more than one shot, without manual reloading, by a single function of the trigger. The term shall also include the frame or receiver of any such weapon, any combination of parts designed and intended to use in converting a weapon into a machinegun, and any combination of parts from which a machinegun can be assembled if such parts are in the possession or under the control of a person

In 1968 there was nothing about “readily converted” to a machine gun, it was “readily restored”. Which means that having an AR-15 lower receiver with M-16/4 parts in it except for the auto-sear is NOT a machine gun by this definition. The receiver would have to be a machine gun receiver. Which in the AR world means the fourth hole.

Nothing in this talks about readily converted to a machine gun. It is all about readily restored to shoot.

Section 921 creates definitions for non NFA items:

  1. As used in this chapter–
    1. The term ‘person’ and the term ‘whoever’ include any individual, corporation, company, association, firm, partnership, society, or joint stock company
    2. The term ‘interstate or foreign commerce’ includes commerce between any place in a State and any place outside of that State, or within any possession of the United States (not including the Canal Zone) or the District of Columbia, but such term does not include commerce between places within the same Sate but through any place outside of that State. The term ‘State’ includes the District of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, and the possessions of the United States (no including the Canal Zone)
    3. The term ‘firearm’ means
      1. any weapon (including a starter gun) which will or is designed to or may readily be converted to expel a projectile by the action of an explosive
      2. the frame or receiver of any such weapon
      3. any firearm muffler or firearm silencer; or
      4. any destructive device.

      Such term does not include an antique firearm.

    4. The term destructive device’ means —
      1. any explosive, incendiary, or poison gas —
        1. bomb
        2. grenade
        3. rocket having a propellant charge of more than four ounces
        4. missile having an explosive or incendiary charge of more than one-quarter ounce
        5. mine, or
        6. device similar to any of the devices described in the preceding clauses
      2. any type of weapon (other than a shotgun or a shotgun shell which the Secretary finds is generally recognized as particularly suitable for sporting purposes) by whatever name known which will, or which may be readily converted to, expel a projectile by the action of an explosive or other propellant, and which has any barrel with a bore of more than one-half inch in diameter; and
      3. Any combination of parts either designed or intended for use in converting any device into any destructive device described in subparagraph (A) or (B) and from which a destructive device may be readily assembled.

      The term ‘destructive device’ shall not include any device which is neither designed nor redesigned for use as a weapon; any device although originally designed for use as a weapon, which is redesigned for use as a signaling, pyrotechnic, line throwing, safety, or similar device; surplus ordnance sold, loaned, or given by the Secretary of the Army pursuant to the provisions of section 4684(2), 4685, or 4686 of title 10; or any other device which the Secretary of the Treasury finds is not likely to be used as a weapon, is an antique, or is a rifle which the owner intends to use solely for sporting purposes.

    5. The term ‘shotgun’ means a weapon designed or redesigned, made or remade, and intended to be fired from the shoulder and designed or redesigned and made or remade to use the energy of the explosive in a fixed shotgun shell to fire through a smooth bore either a number of ball shot or a single projectile for each single pull of the trigger.
    6. The term ‘short-barreled shotgun’ means a shotgun having one or more barrels less than eighteen inches in length and any weapon made from a shotgun (whether by alteration, modification or otherwise) if such weapon is modified has an overall length of less than twenty-six inches.
    7. The term ‘rifle’ means a weapon designed or redesigned, made or remade, and intended to be fired from the shoulder and designed or redesigned and made or remade to use the energy of the explosive in a fixed metallic cartridge to fire only a single projectile through a rifled bore for each single pull of the trigger
    8. The term ‘short-barreled rifle’ means a rifle having one or more barrels less than sixteen inches in length and any weapon made from a rifle (whether by alteration, modification, or otherwise) if such weapon, as modified, has an overall length of less than twenty-six inches.
    9. The term ‘importer’ means …
    10. The term ‘manufacturer’ means any person engaged in the manufacture of firearms or ammunition for purposes of sale or distribution; the term ‘licensed manufacturer’ means any such person licensed under the provisions of this chapter

(That was transcribed from the GCA of 1968. Parts were left out as they are not of interest to us. Parts have been modified since the bill was originally signed into law)

Nowhere in the bill do they define what the term “frame or receiver” means nor do they define what the term “readily” means.

Because congress did not define what a frame or receiver was, the Secretary of the Treasury (ATF) is required to publish that definition.

Firearm: Any weapon, including a starter gun, which will or is designed to or may readily be converted to expel a projectile by the action of an explosive; the frame or receiver of any such weapon; any firearm muffler or firearm silencer; or any destructive device; but the term shall not include an antique firearm. In the case of a licensed collector, the term shall mean only curios and relics. The term shall include a weapon parts kit that is designed to or may readily be completed, assembled, restored, or otherwise converted to expel a projectile by the action of an explosive. The term shall not include a weapon, including a weapon parts kit, in which the frame or receiver of such weapon is destroyed as described in the definition “frame or receiver”.
— 27 CFR 478.11 “Firearm”

Note that this definition of firearm does not match the language of the GCA of 1968. It includes “weapon parts kit”.

Frame or receiver: The term “frame or receiver” shall have the same meaning as in § 478.12.
— 27 CFR 478.11 “Frame or receiver”

This is the current version, hear is the version as of 4/26/2022:

Firearm frame or receiver. That part of a firearm which provides housing for the hammer, bolt or breechblock, and firing mechanism, and which is usually threaded at its forward portion to receive the barrel.
— 27 CFR 478.11 “Firearm frame or receiver” as of 4/26/2022

As of 4/26/2022 there are 37 references to the word “readily” but no definition given.

As of 12/28/2022 there are 50 references and they do define “readily”

Readily. A process, action, or physical state that is fairly or reasonably efficient, quick, and easy, but not necessarily the most efficient, speediest, or easiest process, action, or physical state. With respect to the classification of firearms, factors relevant in making this determination include the following:

  1. Time, i.e., how long it takes to finish the process;
  2. Ease, i.e., how difficult it is to do so;
  3. Expertise, i.e., what knowledge and skills are required;
  4. Equipment, i.e., what tools are required;
  5. Parts availability, i.e., whether additional parts are required, and how easily they can be obtained;
  6. Expense, i.e., how much it costs;
  7. Scope, i.e., the extent to which the subject of the process must be changed to finish it; and
  8. Feasibility, i.e., whether the process would damage or destroy the subject of the process, or cause it to malfunction.

Of course they left all the important parts out. With a manual mill with a DRO it takes me about 5 hours to go from an 80% lower to a functional receiver. If I was doing more, I would create some jigs and I would be able to do it in about 2 hours. Is that readily?

Easy is a relative term. Giving birth is “easy” but I don’t want to go through it nor does my wife want to go through it again. For me, it is “easy” to do the work, for others it isn’t.

Expertise: It is very easy to make mistakes while doing the conversion with a mill. It takes knowledge of what you are doing. With a jig system, it might not take as much skill. It still is not simple.

Equipment: You can buy a mill big enough to do a conversion for around $1000 US. You can not rent or borrow or use somebody else’s mill. You can also invest dollars for jigs, router, drill press and such, still not “cheap”.

Availability is a bogus term. I know the URL of a site where I can purchase a complete select fire fire-control parts kit for an M4/M16. It is as easy as typing in my address and credit card to get that part. Same with 80% lowers and all the other parts. This is just an always unless there is panic buying.

Expense: I remember seeing people bang shovels into AK-47 receivers. Was that readily? It was certainly cheap in cost.

Scope is another “in the eye of the beholder”. I consider the scope of turning an 80% lower into a fully receiver to be much larger than the scope of turning an 80% plastic fantastic into a functional frame. That could be because I’ve not done it.

Feasibility: I’ve got one lower that has a bad trigger slot. I messed up. It still works. On the other hand, I could have miss drilled a single pin hole and totally destroyed me receiver. A friend of mine has a paper weight that looks like an AR15 lower but isn’t and never will be.

Today, every such “failure” is upwards of $100.

All of this is to say that readily is really really in the eye of the beholder. If I had a full CNC machine with tool changer it might very well be that turning an 80% lower into a functional receiver is as simple as pushing the button and waiting for the result popping out 30 minutes later. It might be that doing the same thing to a raw casting takes about the same amount of effort and time. Disregarding all of the setup time and CNC programming time.

At this point, I believe that the entire GCA is going to go away in the next 10 years.