Soft handed people need to STFU
There is a company called Saw Stop which developed a safety system for table saws that detects when a finger touches the blade and applies a brake to the blade to stop the user from getting more than a minor injury.
It’s cool technology, but it’s expensive. A compact Saw Stop table saw us $900. The standard is $2,300.
Replacement brakes are $120.
If that is where this ended, I wouldn’t be posting.
Saw Stop, which is owned by the parent company for Festool, has lobbied to have the federal Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) Saw Stop like safety brake on all new table saws sold in the United States.
Currently Saw Stop is the only manufacturer of this product and therefore would have an instant monopoly.
There is also questions over how Saw Stop would enforce its patent. Saw Stop has said publicly that it would open the patent to the public if the new rule is passed, but it’s still enforcing it the meantime. So their promise is no guarantee of anything.
What this comes down to, is that their is the potential here for a rule change that would make it impossible to go to Lowes or Home Depot and buy a $99 table saw. You might have to buy a safety table saw for several times that.
I am the owner of a $99 after Holiday clearance sale Kobalt table saw. It’s great for $99.
If I had to pay $500 for it, I wouldn’t have bought it because I’d never recoup that value from my saw.
One Congresswoman seems to get this and wants to block the Saw Stop rule.
A new rule mandating finger-detection technology in table saws could raise costs by hundreds of dollars and result in a government-mandated monopoly.
I introduced a bipartisan bill to protect consumer choice and block this mandate until the patents for this tech are made public. pic.twitter.com/vQ26gCvWKG
— Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (@RepMGP) May 15, 2024
She’s right.
The internet attacked her.
we should respect the consumer's choice to have their fingers chopped off by a table saw https://t.co/gkf2QQaz3b
— Nathan J Robinson (@NathanJRobinson) May 17, 2024
Hi ma'am. Greatly respect your work on allowing fingers to be cut off. Thank you
— mr Biden sir youre cheugy (@LaborPal) May 16, 2024
Ah yes the “Let corporations cut off fingers” bill
— ? (@comemenism) May 15, 2024
"You should cut off your own fingers!" is quite a platform to run on.
— Jonathan Vankin (@jonvankin) May 15, 2024
you’re literally pro-fingers getting chopped off lmao
— Mike Figueredo (@HumanistReport) May 16, 2024
Fighting for the right of working-class Americans to lose their fingers! pic.twitter.com/IS7NY97sfS
— Craig Lawrence (@clawrence) May 17, 2024
This is just a sampling.
I’m absolutely convinced every single one of these people has never used a table saw.
I don’t think any if them has ever used a power tool.
These are all soft handed people who do nothing buy touch keyboards all day.
There are two important factors.
Saw Stop saws are very expensive. A portable jobsite Saw Stop Saw is $1,700. A jobsite Saw by Ryobi or Kobalt could be had for $300. Even a DeWalt is $600.
Ignoring the patent, there are embedded costs from adding circuit boards, sensors, and the electronics for the brake.
Low cost homeowner hobbyists table saws will disappear.
Businesses will have to pay out significantly more for saws.
Likely, small businesses and independent contractors will simply stop using table saws and switch to circular saws.
The reality is that most table saw injuries come from improper use. Failing to use guards or pushing tools.
Businesses, tradesmen, and hobbyists have been using table saws for years without being injured because they use them correctly .
But these doofuses know they can’t be trusted to use a saw without hurting themselves so they want safety mandated, at the expense of cost efficient saws.
They take a stance of moral superiority instead of incompetence.
People like this should be ignored, because they are the sorts of idiots who stab themselves trying to take the pit out of an avocado, they can’t run a table saw.